A mother in her early 30s is reading the book “Pinocchio” to her four-year-old son. They are sitting on a couch in their living room.
Mom: (Turns to final page.) “Never again, Pinocchio decided, would he tell another lie.” (Shuts book.)
Timmy: Mommy…your tummy is fat.
Mom: What?
Timmy: Your tummy is fat.
Mom: Timmy, that’s not a very nice thing to say.
Timmy: I’m just telling the truth.
Mom: Sometimes, sweetie, it’s best to keep the truth to yourself.
Timmy: Oh. (Pauses.) Read it again?
Mom: Sure. (Opens the book.) “Once upon a time, there was a toymaker named Geppetto. Geppetto loved children, but had none of his own-“
Timmy: Why doesn’t he have children?
Mom: Because he’s not married.
Timmy: Is that ‘cause no one loves him?
Mom: No, honey, it’s because he hasn’t found the right person yet.
Timmy: Oh. Is Daddy the right person for you then?
Mom: Yes, Timmy.
Timmy: Then why do you yell at him?
Mom: (Laughs.) Because sometimes he can be annoying.
Timmy: Is that why you yell at me? Because I’m annoying?
Mom: (Hesitates.) Let’s just keep reading. “Geppetto could make wonderful things out of wood. One day he made a puppet that looked just like a boy. He called the puppet Pinocchio…” (The lights dim, then come back on.) “This was not true. Suddenly, Pinocchio’s nose started to grow longer-“
Timmy: (Hurriedly.) Mommy, I don’t like carrots.
Mom: …Okay.
Timmy: I don’t like it when you make pasta, either.
Mom: Timmy, what did I tell you about saying nice things?
Timmy: But Mommy, I don’t want my nose to get bigger.
Mom: What?
Timmy: When Pinocchio lied, his nose got bigger.
Mom: It’s just a story, Timmy.
Timmy: (Unconvinced.) Okay.
Mom: (The lights dim, then come back on.) “Right away his nose grew still longer.”
Timmy: (Begins to cry.)
Mom: Baby, what’s wrong?
Timmy: O-one time, you s-said I couldn’t h-have a c-cookie, and…and…and I ate it anyway!
Mom: (Shuts book.) Okay, Timmy, I think you’re taking this story way too seriously. Your nose won’t actually grow longer if you tell a lie.
Timmy: (Sniffs.) Th-then why d-does it h-happen to P-P-Pinocchio?
Mom: Because Pinocchio is fake, sweetie. He’s a character in a made-up story.
Timmy: (Horrified, stops crying.) Pinocchio isn’t…real?
Mom: No, no, honey, uh, he…he’s real, all right. It’s just, uh, his…his nose just doesn’t actually grow when he tells a lie.
Timmy: (Unbelieving.) Oh.
Mom: The point is, Timmy, that it’s not a good thing to lie, but you should try to keep the truth to yourself if it will hurt someone’s feelings.
Timmy: But Mommy, when Pinocchio didn’t tell the truth, he got into lots of trouble and his nose kept getting more bigger and more bigger.
Mom: (Sighs.) I know, Timmy, but that’s because…it’s because he was a puppet! Yeah, that’s why. That’s what will happen to you if you’re a puppet. Which you’re not. You’re a real little boy.
Timmy: So it’s okay if I lie?
Mom: No, Tim-
Timmy: It’s okay if I don’t tell you that I broke the lamp and hid it under the couch ‘till Daddy found it and said he did it so I wouldn’t get in lots of trouble? It’s okay if I say that my tummy hurts so I don’t have to eat dinner when you make yucky food? It’s okay if I say that you look pretty even when I’m just kidding? It’s okay-
Mom: Timmy! Stop, stop, stop! None of that is okay! (Pauses.) Well, except for maybe that last one, but still! It’s not a good thing to tell a lie-
Timmy: But you said it’s okay to tell lies…were you lying?
Mom: (Sighs.) No, Timmy, I wasn’t lying. What I meant was sometimes you have to use tact when telling people things.
Timmy: What does tact mean?
Mom: It means being aware of how other people feel and tell them things while keeping their feelings in mind.
Timmy: …What does it mean?
Mom: It means, if someone looks ugly, will you tell him or her they look ugly?
Timmy: Yes.
Mom: (Shakes head, sighing.) No, Timmy, you shouldn’t.
Timmy: But then that’s lying.
Mom: No, that’s being tactful.
Timmy: So being…tac-…tact-…tactful means lying?
Mom: No, it means making sure you don’t hurt anyone’s feelings.
Timmy: Does that mean that telling the truth hurts people’s feelings, then?
Mom: Well…(Pauses.) Well, sometimes it does. But I still want you to always tell the truth. Just, sometimes, don’t tell all of the truth.
Timmy: You want me to lie a little bit?
Mom: No, I want you to be tactful. (Smiles. Silence. Timmy looks very confused. Sighs.) Listen, Timmy, how would you feel if I said I didn’t like that Lego ship you built me earlier before?
Timmy: I’d be super sad because that’s not very nice, Mommy. You said you loved it!
Mom: And I do love it, sweetie. But let’s pretend that I didn’t love it, and I thought it was kinda ugly, which it isn’t, it’s beautiful, but we’re just pretending.
Timmy: We’re pretending? Are we playing a game now?
Mom: Sorta…Yeah, I guess so. Anyway, we’re pretending that I didn’t like your Lego ship, but I didn’t want to hurt your feelings because I love you so much. So I told you that I thought it was great. I’m not really lying; I’m just being tactful so I won’t hurt your feelings.
Timmy: So…so you’re not telling the whole truth?
Mom: Exactly! Just like I said before! Not telling the whole truth is called a “little white lie.” Telling those doesn’t hurt anybody’s feelings and it’s not a wrong thing to do, either.
Timmy: Oh…why are they little and white?
Mom: Uh…I’m not sure, but do you understand what I mean?
Timmy: I think so, Mommy.
Mom: So you’ll try to be more tactful from now on?
Timmy: I’ll try, Mommy.
Mom: Does that mean you still think I have a fat tummy?
Timmy: Oh no, Mommy, you’re the skinniest, beautifullest person in the whole wide world! (Places his hand on his nose and feels it with apprehension.)
ROFL. I'm wondering if this is based in reality, maybe just the littlest bit?
ReplyDelete